This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.
Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping Free shipping when you spend $333

Shop Our Valentine's Day Guide

Book a Custom Consultation

Book Permanent Jewelry!

Lovingly and ethically made in Philadelphia

New customers save 10% with code GET10

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping Spend $300 for free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Products
Pair with
Is this a gift?
Subtotal Free
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

SALT AND PEPPER DIAMONDS

Our most coveted Salt and Pepper Diamonds from the top selling ethical diamond vendor, Misfit Diamonds

Filter

Color
Shape
Cut
Other
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
 
in stock

0.28ct 5.21x3.59x2.29mm Oval Brilliant 25694-05

$357.00

 
in stock

0.58ct 5.02x4.43x2.37mm Rectangle Rosecut 19057-02

$431.00

 
in stock

0.44ct 7.37x3.98x2.45mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-44

$524.00

 
in stock

0.59ct 6.96x4.34x2.80mm Pear Brilliant 🇨🇦 27292-01

$537.00

 
in stock

0.52ct 8.01x4.10x2.58mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-12

$620.00

 
in stock

0.54ct 7.24x4.23x2.89mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-55

$643.00

 
in stock

0.56ct 7.30x4.29x2.94mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-26

$666.00

 
in stock

0.59ct 8.03x4.47x2.75mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-36

$702.00

 
in stock

0.60ct 8.05x4.24x2.90mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-27

$713.00

 
in stock

0.63ct 5.23x5.19x2.72mm Round Rosecut 🇨🇦 27283-01

$715.00

 
in stock

0.61ct 8.22x4.41x2.88mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-22

$726.00

 
in stock

0.61ct 8.61x4.40x2.83mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-35

$726.00

 
in stock

0.63ct 7.72x4.31x3.03mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-51

$749.00

 
in stock

0.56ct 7.32x4.77x2.32mm Trapezoid Step Cut 25458-10

$759.00

 
in stock

1.05ct 6.99x5.23x3.57mm Oval Brilliant 🇨🇦 26992-01

$781.00

 
in stock

0.68ct 8.20x4.26x3.18mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-04

$808.00

 
in stock

0.69ct 8.35x4.67x2.87mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-29

$821.00

 
in stock

0.57ct 5.52x4.75x2.58mm Hexagon Rosecut 25457-17

$829.00

 
in stock

0.64ct 6.58x4.43x2.52mm Cut Corner Rectangle Step Cut 🇨🇦 26889-01

$863.00

 
in stock

0.73ct 8.03x4.59x3.36mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-54

$868.00

 
in stock

0.49ct 5.42x3.99x2.46mm Cut Corner Rectangle Step Cut 🇨🇦 27080-01

$868.00

 
in stock

0.85ct 5.23x4.77x3.46mm Cut Corner Rectangle Step Cut 🇨🇦 26895-01

$901.00

 
in stock

0.76ct 8.03x4.77x3.35mm Marquise Brilliant 27226-16

$904.00

 
in stock

0.59ct 6.19x7.25x2.22mm Triangle Rosecut 26787-17

$908.00