This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.
Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping Free shipping when you spend $333

Shop Our Valentine's Day Guide

Book a Custom Consultation

Book Permanent Jewelry!

Lovingly and ethically made in Philadelphia

New customers save 10% with code GET10

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping Spend $300 for free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Products
Pair with
Is this a gift?
Subtotal Free
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

SALT AND PEPPER DIAMONDS

Our most coveted Salt and Pepper Diamonds from the top selling ethical diamond vendor, Misfit Diamonds

Filter

Color
Shape
Cut
Other
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
 
in stock

2.12ct 7.23x7.12x4.94mm Cushion Brilliant 🇨🇦 27274-01

$3,956.00

 
in stock

2.15ct 8.22x7.05x4.94mm Hexagon Step Cut 🇨🇦 27273-01

$4,013.00

 
in stock

2.13ct 7.62x6.31x5.38mm Octahedron 🇨🇦 24929-01

$4,030.00

 
in stock

3.75ct 11.28x8.38x4.62mm Hexagon Step Cut 23841-07

$4,098.00

 
in stock

3.51ct 9.68x9.67x5.94mm Round Brilliant 20025-11

$4,106.00

 
in stock

3.04ct 8.99x8.96x5.87mm Round Brilliant 27051-02

$4,125.00

4.02ct 11.48x9.03x4.78mm Pear Double Cut 19062-05 - Misfit Diamonds
 
4.02ct 11.48x9.03x4.78mm Pear Double Cut 19062-05 - Misfit Diamonds
4.02ct 11.48x9.03x4.78mm Pear Double Cut 19062-05 - Misfit Diamonds
in stock

4.02ct 11.48x9.03x4.78mm Pear Double Cut 19062-05

$4,125.00

 
in stock

1.61ct 10.33x7.09x4.53mm Kite Step Cut 🇨🇦 26928-01

$4,154.00

 
in stock

3.08ct 8.99x8.76x6.08mm Round Brilliant 27051-01

$4,189.00

 
in stock

3.89ct 8.91x8.61x6.82mm Octahedron 🇨🇦 25565-01

$4,275.00

 
in stock

5.33ct 13.12x8.39x5.29mm Pear Double Cut 26806-01

$4,318.00

 
in stock

3.26ct 9.16x9.10x5.86mm Round Brilliant 27051-03

$4,350.00

 
in stock

3.13ct 9.23x9.21x5.78mm Round Brilliant 20025-08

$4,362.00

 
in stock

3.39ct 10.76x8.51x4.70mm Pear Double Cut 27236-01

$4,394.00

 
in stock

2.63ct 7.99x8.62x5.48mm Heart Brilliant 26804-01

$4,475.00

 
in stock

2.83ct 8.96x6.70x4.51mm Cut Corner Rectangle Step Cut 27241-06

$4,493.00

3.66ct 9.57x9.54x6.16mm Round Brilliant 18929-09 - Misfit Diamonds
 
3.66ct 9.57x9.54x6.16mm Round Brilliant 18929-09 - Misfit Diamonds
in stock

3.66ct 9.57x9.54x6.16mm Round Brilliant 18929-09

$4,512.00

 
in stock

3.31ct 9.21x9.19x6.01mm Round Brilliant 20025-05

$4,613.00

 
in stock

3.54ct 9.42x9.39x6.29mm Round Brilliant 19195-16

$4,677.00

 
in stock

2.43ct 8.38x7.07x5.26mm Cushion Brilliant 🇨🇦 26907-01

$4,724.00

 
in stock

4.38ct 9.52x9.43x4.10mm Square Rosecut 19622-06

$4,826.00

 
in stock

4.08ct 9.53x9.55x6.47mm Round Brilliant 23185-06

$4,859.00

 
in stock

4.29ct 9.06x11.29x4.8mm Trapezoid Rosecut 25479-01

$5,039.00

 
in stock

2.45ct 8.42x8.31x5.34mm Round Brilliant 19914-02

$5,147.00